.

.

WE NEED YOUR HELP

The Capital City Citizens' Committee is firmly of the view that the current City of Perth Act is fatally-flawed and a missed opportunity to create a great capital city for Western Australia. BUT WE NEED YOUR HELP.

Write, email, phone or lobby your local Member of the Legislative Assembly and Members of the Legislative Council. You can find their names and contact details at http://www.parliament.wa.gov.au/parliament/memblist.nsf/WebCurrMembElectorate Just type the name of your suburb or your postcode into the 'search' box and click on the 'Search' button.

Feel free to use information on this blog to help you make the case.

Thank you all.

Saturday, 10 October 2015

CoP Bill Clause 37 Would Be Cancer

Not for the first time, Local Government Minister, Tony Simpson, appears not to understand his own proposed legislation ('Bid to block Burswood land grab', West Australian, 9th October, 2015). 

The concern with the last clause of the City of Perth Bill is not that the Local Government Advisory Board (LGAB) might 'change its tune' over Burswood and the City of Perth, as Simpson claims, but that it changes the basis on which the LGAB is required to assess any proposal for such a change.

It would do so by requiring that the LGAB, in addition to its current criteria, "have regard to the special significance of the role and responsibilities of the City of Perth that flow from Perth being the capital of Western Australia", but without defining the "role and responsibilities". In practice, such definition would be derived from any proposal made by the City of Perth itself or by the Minister for Local Government or from Government policy communicated to the Board.

We know that the Premier, the Minister and the City of Perth all still want the Burswood Peninsula to be in the City of Perth. The City of Perth has also cast covetous eyes on the commercial areas of both Subiaco and Vincent.

The clause that Minister Simpson so disingenuously casts as benign would, in practice, be a cancer allowing the City of Perth to grow on its own terms.
West Australian, 9th October, 2015

Tuesday, 6 October 2015

Victoria Park (Council and MLA) Join Battle

Some of us have been concerned that the ALP Opposition has been leaving too many doors open to accepting an amended City of Perth Bill, with removal of clause 37 (requiring the Local Government Advisory Board to consider unspecified 'capital city' role and function for boundary change porposals for the City of Perth) being its single 'non-negotiable'.

In today's Southern Gazette, Victoria Park MLA, Ben Wyatt, in conjunction with Town of Victoria Park CEO, Antony Vuletta, appears to say the ALP will draw the line at (at the very least) requiring removal of both Clause 37 and Clause 29. 


Clause 29 is the clause that gives powers to the Executive Director Public Health - but only over Kings Park. It is the Local Government Legislation Amendment Bill, also before the Parliament right now, that contains the same provision for all A-Class reserves, but the CoP Bill would, if passed, set a precedent.


Even if the City of Perth Bill is defeated, the Local Government Legislation Amendment Bill is also a threat on the same basis.


Both Bills must be defeated before Kings Park and Burswood (not to mention Subiaco and Vincent) are safe.

Southern Gazette, 6th October 2015




Monday, 5 October 2015

A New Light on the City of Perth Committee?


It is interesting that the Premier reportedly has said that "if one of his ministers had behaved in this way he would probably look at resignation"(https://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/wa/a/29725980/lord-mayor-digs-in-over-ccc-findings).

This has been hanging over the Lord Mayor for some time. Does it cast new light on the way the City of Perth Committee has been framed in the City of Perth Bill - vaguely enough to allow an effective state government takeover of the City of Perth on major development and infrastructure issues? 

Do the findings of the CCC potentially give the Premier 'justification' for doing so if the City of Perth Bill passes the Parliament?

Of course the Bill has yet to pass the Parliament - and there are strong doubts as to whether it will - but the CCCC will continue to be vigilant and lobby for rejection of the Bill in its entirety. 
https://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/wa/a/29723044/lisa-scaffidi-failed-to-declare-gifts-travel-ccc

Wednesday, 23 September 2015

UPDATE: Draft Hansard available.

The draft Hansard record of today's debate on the City of Perth Bill is in two parts and can be downloaded from http://parliament.wa.gov.au/Hansard/hansard.nsf/0/50f05f45f5b5442948257ec90036103a/$FILE/A39+S1+20150923+p5b-17a.pdf and http://www.parliament.wa.gov.au/Hansard/hansard.nsf/0/ffe04193eeb84ebe48257ec900361703/$FILE/A39+S1+20150923+p27d-38a.pdf

CoP Bill Debate Under Way

Wednesday 23 September saw the first day of debate on the City of Perth Bill in the Legislative Assembly. We'll post the Hansard here when it's available (draft should be available tonight).

Key points from the debate so far.

David Templeman (ALP, Mandurah. Opposition spokesperson on local government). Main issue is clause 37, which allows Government or City of Perth to claim Burswood. Serious questions about Kings Park and Executive Director Public Health and the proposed City of Perth Committee.

Ben Wyatt (ALP, Victoria Park). Slams Government for previous shambolic 'reform'. Argues that clause 37 is there to allow Premier to put Burswood into City of Perth despite demonstrated and overwhelming community opposition.

Dave Kelly (ALP, Bassendean). Premier wanted Vincent in City of Perth but only with gerrymander to ensure business domination. Vincent people objected. Describes clause 37 as 'legislative spaghetti', obscure, ambiguous, complicated, contentious and trojan horse to achieve Premier's will.

Terry Redman (Warren-Blackwood, Leader of the National Party). National Party is not against local government reform but will oppose this Bill on the grounds of forced amalgamation. [Note: This is the first time the Nationals have used the word 'oppose' as distinct from 'not support' - the latter being ambiguous as it could simply mean abstain.]

Mark McGowan (Leader, ALP, Rockingham). Really had a go at Barnett on the City of Perth Bill being the last vestige of local government reform fiasco. However, he stated that the Opposition's sticking point was clause 37

Vince Catania (National, North West Central) said that only the Nationals have a consistent policy on local government reform and this reflects the views of regional WA communities. The National Party will maintain that consistent policy. Local councils and communities deserve better from both Government and Opposition.

Debate was adjourned for the day with Rita Saffioti (ALP, West Swan) speaking. She will resume speaking when the debate is resumed - presumably tomorrow (Thursday 24th September).

In summary, the Nationals oppose the Bill, on the basis of the forced changes for residents of Subiaco. ALP opposes on the basis that Clause 37 opens the gate for Burswood to be moved to City of Perth and has some other substantial questions - but could support the Bill if Cl 37 removed and questions answered to its satisfaction.

If ALP and Nationals vote against and one Liberal crosses the floor, the votes will be tied 29 for and 29 against. Does the Speaker have a casting vote - and how would he use it? The Speaker should be aware of Denison's Rule.

Denison's rule is a convention, derived from the UK and the House of Commons, that the Speaker's casting vote should always be in favour of further debate or, where no further debate is possible, to vote in favour of the status quo. The principle behind the convention is that change should only occur if an actual majority is in favour of that change.
http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-information-office/p09.pdf
Denison's rule is a guiding principle also in many non-parliamentary bodies that have neutral chairpersons.

Monday, 21 September 2015

ALP Fires The First Shot

With the City of Perth Bill high on the notice paper for the Legislative Assembly this week, the ALP has broken its silence and fired the first shot (excuse the mixed metaphors).

In saying it will not support clause 37 of the Bill, which facilitates City of Perth takeover of adjoining areas, including Burswood and the commercial areas of Vincent and Subiaco, the ALP is reflecting concerns expressed by all neighbouring councils.

But the City of Perth Bill is far more flawed than this opening salvo suggests. South Perth, Subiaco, Nedlands and Claremont Councils have passed more far-reaching resolutions effectively calling for the City of Perth Bill to be abandoned or defeated because it is so fundamentally flawed.

And the 3000 residents of Subiaco who the Bill would forcibly shift into the City of Perth wouldn't be too pleased about the ALP "support[ing] expanding Perth's boundaries", although that could be a ploy to get Barnett to accept removal of clause 37 (potential future expansion) in order to get expansion now.

However, there are many, many more reasons to oppose the City of Perth Bill (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/09/why-city-of-perth-bill-is-fatally-flawed.html) - it doesn't all hinge on boundaries.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-09-21/wa-opposition-threatens-to-block-city-of-perth-boundary-expansi/6792922

What Our Capital City Really Needs

In an earlier post (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/09/why-city-of-perth-bill-is-fatally-flawed.html) we set out the reasons why all of us should be very concerned about the Government's attempt to foist an ill-thought-out and fatally-flawed City of Perth Bill on us in the name of creating a great capital city for WA.

We are aware that simply expressing our concerns will be taken by some as being negative, but in fact we support the creation of a more effective capital city for Western Australia. The current Bill, however, is so flawed that we believe it should be withdrawn or defeated and something better put in its place. 

As a positive contribution to this, the CCCC has developed a framework document for a capital city (attached), which we respectfully request that you consider when responding to the current Bill. The first part of our document reviews practice in all Australian state Capital Cities (no two cities are the same). The last page and a half sets out what we consider to be the essential principles and legislative requirements for a truly great capital city, including involvement of all stakeholders, openness and accountability, and establishment of a means for effective implementation of agreed policies, strategies and plans.
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge