.

.

WE NEED YOUR HELP

The Capital City Citizens' Committee is firmly of the view that the current City of Perth Act is fatally-flawed and a missed opportunity to create a great capital city for Western Australia. BUT WE NEED YOUR HELP.

Write, email, phone or lobby your local Member of the Legislative Assembly and Members of the Legislative Council. You can find their names and contact details at http://www.parliament.wa.gov.au/parliament/memblist.nsf/WebCurrMembElectorate Just type the name of your suburb or your postcode into the 'search' box and click on the 'Search' button.

Feel free to use information on this blog to help you make the case.

Thank you all.
Showing posts with label City of Perth Committee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label City of Perth Committee. Show all posts

Friday, 20 November 2015

Labor Shafts The Subiaco 3000

In the previous local government so-called reform process, Labor was left at the post and only started to make up some ground when it became clear that community opposition was gathering such momentum that it might, against all the odds, actually succeed.

With the City of Perth Bill, after appearing to promise so much, Labor went to water and abandoned the residents of Subiaco's south ward when the numbers were there to defeat the Bill outright.

And as for Labor's agreeing to broaden the scope of the Bill to allow for transparency and accountability requirements for all local governments, the best that can be said for that is that it was a misuse of parliamentary process to do it so late, without consultation and via a Bill that otherwise did not directly affect other local governments except Subiaco and Nedlands.

Thanks to the Nationals and to Rob Johnson for having, and sticking to, principles. And thanks to Chris Tallentire (ALP, Gosnells), who at least spoke up for the Subiaco 3000 even if he couldn't find it in himself to vote against the party line. See how your local member voted (foot of this post - two Nationals, Terry Redman and Brendan Grylls were absent but we know they would have voted against the Bill) and let them know if you are disgusted by the way the Subiaco residents have been treated simply to make life a little easier for the University of WA (see Mark McGowan's comment in the first part (columns 4 and 5) of the Post article below).

I must admit, though, that I did like Ben Wyatt's characterisation of the Bill's passing the Legislative Assembly as "The Premier has snatched a committee from the jaws of defeat", for there is very little else of substance in the Bill apart from the forced relocation of the Subiaco 3000. Even with little substance, however, it would still be bad law if passed by the Legislative Council.

Needless to say, the mainstream media (ABC and the West Australian) homed in on the accountability aspect and almost entirely ignored the fundamental issues in the City of Perth Bill. As too often has been the case over the past couple of years, notwithstanding some important contributions from the ABC, it was left to the Post to provide a more rounded coverage.


Wednesday, 18 November 2015

Update On ALP Deal-With-The-Devil

Debate on the City of Perth Bill has ended for the day. There are still 15 clauses to go - one of which (clause 37) must automatically be removed from the Bill as a consequence of the successful Opposition amendment, Clause 15A.

Below is an update of the previous post (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/11/has-alp-done-deal-with-devil.html) which outlined what the CCCC has achieved in respect of the nine key issues.

1.    The Bill does little or nothing to improve the governance of the Capital City. Far from improving and strengthening the City of Perth, the City of Perth Committee (Cl 12-15) would weaken it. The proposed ‘City of Perth Committee’ would not be accountable to the Parliament, the Perth City Council or the community. 

This appears to have gone through to the keeper, with Simpson stating that the Committee doesn't even have to keep minutes, never mind making them public. The Opposition barely batted a collective eyelid when Simpson said this.

It is worth noting, however, that Local Government Minister, Tony Simpson, stated in Parliament that the City of Perth Committee does not have to keep minutes, let alone make them publicly-available (Clause 15 - 'Committee may regulate own procedure').

This is a surprising assertion, but was allowed to go unchallenged, as not to do so would surely be in breach of the State Records Act, 2000, which applies to, inter alia:
5.    A Minister of the Crown. 
9.    An incorporated or unincorporated body established or continued for a public purpose under a written law. 
12.  A local government or regional local government under the Local Government Act 1995 . 
15.  A commission, board, committee or other body established by, or a person appointed by, the Governor or the Government of the State or a Minister of the Crown to advise on, inquire into or investigate any matter. 

It would also seem to be contrary to the accountability and reporting requirements of the Local Government Act, 1995, at least as far as the participation of the City of Perth is concerned.

2.    The proposal for City of Perth boundaries (Cl 17/18) runs counter to key criteria for assessment of boundary change or amalgamation proposals, including: ‘community of interest’ and ‘natural barriers’ (‘physical and topographic features’ and ‘transport and communications’). 

3.    Jurisdictional separation of UWA and QEII from their surrounding communities (Cl 17/18) endangers the partnerships built up over many years for joint projects with Subiaco and Nedlands Councils. 

4.    Extending the CoP boundary to the middle of the river (Cl 17/18) creates a precedent and uncertainty for local government maintenance responsibilities and cost-shifting. 

Debate on Clauses 17 and 18 was entirely about the boundary being in the middle of the Swan River.

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not affect river management (still with Parks and Wildlife) but is purely to allow CoP to manage health and similar issues on structures over the river. He stated more than once that the final responsibility for river management and developments on/in river is Parks and Wildlife.

Residents of Subiaco didn’t even rate a mention before the clauses were passed. This is a gross dereliction of duty by our elected representatives in the Legislative Assembly.

5.    The City of Perth has repeatedly said that it doesn’t want residential areas. 

No mention – and don’t expect one now.

6.     The Bill repeals (Cl 27) the City of Perth Restructuring Act, 1993, which established Vincent, Victoria Park and Cambridge, with the effect of disestablishing those local governments. 

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not disestablish City of Vincent, Town of Victoria Park or Town of Cambridge.

7.    The Bill creates uncertainty about future changes to boundaries of the City of Perth, including Burswood, by requiring the Local Government Advisory Board to take account of ‘capital city status’ without defining what it means (Cl 37). 

The Opposition amendment (clause 15A) that any future changes to City of Perth boundaries require an Act of Parliament has been passed. This means that clause 37 has to be removed.

8.    There are no benefits from including Kings Park in the City of Perth (Cl 17/18). Doing so may create pressure for inappropriate development in the Park, especially with the additional powers given to the Executive Director of Public Health (Cl 29/30). 

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not give EDPH any more powers than he already has under the Health Act. This is important, given that the wording in the City of Perth is different from that in the Health Act.

9.    Business/property owner voting enrolment would not expire unless the enrolee notifies the City of Perth (Cl 20/21), creating potential for rorting the system or simple inertia to entrench business votes. 

These clauses were voted down without a formal division being required.

It looks to me that:
- 7 and 9 have been achieved;
- a reasonable amount has been achieved on 4, 6 and 8 (at least through clear statements that can be taken to be the intent of Parliament when passing the Act), 
- 1, 2, 3, and 5 have been lost

Whilst this is not a bad achievement for a voluntary group of concerned citizens, this will be of small comfort to the residents of Subiaco who are now almost certain to find themselves involuntary and unwanted citizens of the City of Perth.

Tuesday, 17 November 2015

Nationals Stick To Principles - But Has ALP Done A Deal With The Devil?

It would be unusual for a Government Bill to be defeated at the Second Reading Stage, but that could have happened to the City of Perth Bill yesterday in the Legislative Assembly. That only the Nationals voted against further consideration of the Bill raises suspicions that the Labor Opposition has done a deal with the Barnett Government (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/11/has-alp-done-deal-with-devil.html).

Anyway, we congratulate Terry Redman and the Nationals for sticking to their principles to oppose forced amalgamations.

Has ALP Done A Deal With The Devil?

Has the ALP done a deal with Barnett over the City of Perth Bill?

It appears from what passed for debate in the Legislative Assembly yesterday (Tuesday, 17th November) that:
-    The ALP has supported the Government’s extension of the City of Perth Bill to impose requirements on all local governments. Whatever the merits of the transparency/accountability requirements, it is inappropriate to use legislation specific to one local government in this way. The correct way of adding such requirements is through amending the Local Government Act directly.
-    The Government has accepted the Opposition’s ‘non-negotiable’ removal of clause 37 (see point 7, below) and even its proposed amendment that any future change to City of Perth boundaries should require an Act of Parliament.

If this is correct, the ALP has put itself in an invidious position. In supporting expansion of the scope of the Bill (for transparency/accountability matters) to all local governments, the Opposition has allowed itself to be wedged - if it now votes against the Bill, Barnett will accuse it of hypocrisy and not being serious about accountability.

If the Opposition does roll over, it’s worth a look at what has been achieved in respect of the nine key issues identified by the CCCC.

1.     The Bill does little or nothing to improve the governance of the Capital City. Far from improving and strengthening the City of Perth, the City of Perth Committee (Cl 12-15) would weaken it. The proposed ‘City of Perth Committee’ would not be accountable to the Parliament, the Perth City Council or the community. 

This appears to have gone through to the keeper, with Simpson stating that the Committee doesn't even have to keep minutes, never mind making them public. The Opposition barely batted a collective eyelid when Simpson said this.

It is worth noting, however, that Local Government Minister, Tony Simpson, stated in Parliament that the City of Perth Committee does not have to keep minutes, let alone make them publicly-available (Clause 15 - 'Committee may regulate own procedure').

This is a surprising assertion, but was allowed to go unchallenged, as not to do so would surely be in breach of the State Records Act, 2000, which applies to, inter alia:
5.    A Minister of the Crown. 
9.    An incorporated or unincorporated body established or continued for a public purpose under a written law. 
12.  A local government or regional local government under the Local Government Act 1995 . 
15.  A commission, board, committee or other body established by, or a person appointed by, the Governor or the Government of the State or a Minister of the Crown to advise on, inquire into or investigate any matter. 

It would also seem to be contrary to the accountability and reporting requirements of the Local Government Act, 1995, at least as far as the participation of the City of Perth is concerned.

2.    The proposal for City of Perth boundaries (Cl 17/18) runs counter to key criteria for assessment of boundary change or amalgamation proposals, including: ‘community of interest’ and ‘natural barriers’ (‘physical and topographic features’ and ‘transport and communications’). 

This has not yet been debated.

3.    Jurisdictional separation of UWA and QEII from their surrounding communities (Cl 17/18) endangers the partnerships built up over many years for joint projects with Subiaco and Nedlands Councils. 

This has not yet been debated.

4.    Extending the CoP boundary to the middle of the river (Cl 17/18) creates a precedent and uncertainty for local government maintenance responsibilities and cost-shifting. 

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not affect river management (still with Parks and Wildlife) but is purely to allow CoP to manage health and similar issues on structures over the river. He stated more than once that the final responsibility for river management and developments on/in river is Parks and Wildlife.

5.    The City of Perth has repeatedly said that it doesn’t want residential areas. 

No mention yet.

6.     The Bill repeals (Cl 27) the City of Perth Restructuring Act, 1993, which established Vincent, Victoria Park and Cambridge, with the effect of disestablishing those local governments. 

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not disestablish City of Vincent, Town of Victoria Park or Town of Cambridge.

7.    The Bill creates uncertainty about future changes to boundaries of the City of Perth, including Burswood, by requiring the Local Government Advisory Board to take account of ‘capital city status’ without defining what it means (Cl 37). 

Simpson appears to have said that the Government agrees to removal of clause 37 and to Opposition amendment that any future changes to City of Perth boundaries require Act of Parliament.

8.    There are no benefits from including Kings Park in the City of Perth (Cl 17/18). Doing so may create pressure for inappropriate development in the Park, especially with the additional powers given to the Executive Director of Public Health (Cl 29/30). 

Explicit statement from Simpson in Parliament that this does not give EDPH any more powers than he already has under the Health Act. This is important, given that the wording in the City of Perth is different from that in the Health Act.

9.    Business/property owner voting enrolment would not expire unless the enrolee notifies the City of Perth (Cl 20/21), creating potential for rorting the system or simple inertia to entrench business votes. 

This has not yet been debated.

It looks to me that a reasonable amount has been achieved on 4, 6, 7 and 8 (at least through clear statements that can be taken to be the intent of Parliament when passing the Act), but the state of 1 is a great disappointment - the remainder (2, 3, 5, and 9) have not yet been debated. Simpson has batted off the issue of clause 20 so far, so this could still end up as the deal-breaker.

Monday, 5 October 2015

A New Light on the City of Perth Committee?


It is interesting that the Premier reportedly has said that "if one of his ministers had behaved in this way he would probably look at resignation"(https://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/wa/a/29725980/lord-mayor-digs-in-over-ccc-findings).

This has been hanging over the Lord Mayor for some time. Does it cast new light on the way the City of Perth Committee has been framed in the City of Perth Bill - vaguely enough to allow an effective state government takeover of the City of Perth on major development and infrastructure issues? 

Do the findings of the CCC potentially give the Premier 'justification' for doing so if the City of Perth Bill passes the Parliament?

Of course the Bill has yet to pass the Parliament - and there are strong doubts as to whether it will - but the CCCC will continue to be vigilant and lobby for rejection of the Bill in its entirety. 
https://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/wa/a/29723044/lisa-scaffidi-failed-to-declare-gifts-travel-ccc

Wednesday, 23 September 2015

UPDATE: Draft Hansard available.

The draft Hansard record of today's debate on the City of Perth Bill is in two parts and can be downloaded from http://parliament.wa.gov.au/Hansard/hansard.nsf/0/50f05f45f5b5442948257ec90036103a/$FILE/A39+S1+20150923+p5b-17a.pdf and http://www.parliament.wa.gov.au/Hansard/hansard.nsf/0/ffe04193eeb84ebe48257ec900361703/$FILE/A39+S1+20150923+p27d-38a.pdf

CoP Bill Debate Under Way

Wednesday 23 September saw the first day of debate on the City of Perth Bill in the Legislative Assembly. We'll post the Hansard here when it's available (draft should be available tonight).

Key points from the debate so far.

David Templeman (ALP, Mandurah. Opposition spokesperson on local government). Main issue is clause 37, which allows Government or City of Perth to claim Burswood. Serious questions about Kings Park and Executive Director Public Health and the proposed City of Perth Committee.

Ben Wyatt (ALP, Victoria Park). Slams Government for previous shambolic 'reform'. Argues that clause 37 is there to allow Premier to put Burswood into City of Perth despite demonstrated and overwhelming community opposition.

Dave Kelly (ALP, Bassendean). Premier wanted Vincent in City of Perth but only with gerrymander to ensure business domination. Vincent people objected. Describes clause 37 as 'legislative spaghetti', obscure, ambiguous, complicated, contentious and trojan horse to achieve Premier's will.

Terry Redman (Warren-Blackwood, Leader of the National Party). National Party is not against local government reform but will oppose this Bill on the grounds of forced amalgamation. [Note: This is the first time the Nationals have used the word 'oppose' as distinct from 'not support' - the latter being ambiguous as it could simply mean abstain.]

Mark McGowan (Leader, ALP, Rockingham). Really had a go at Barnett on the City of Perth Bill being the last vestige of local government reform fiasco. However, he stated that the Opposition's sticking point was clause 37

Vince Catania (National, North West Central) said that only the Nationals have a consistent policy on local government reform and this reflects the views of regional WA communities. The National Party will maintain that consistent policy. Local councils and communities deserve better from both Government and Opposition.

Debate was adjourned for the day with Rita Saffioti (ALP, West Swan) speaking. She will resume speaking when the debate is resumed - presumably tomorrow (Thursday 24th September).

In summary, the Nationals oppose the Bill, on the basis of the forced changes for residents of Subiaco. ALP opposes on the basis that Clause 37 opens the gate for Burswood to be moved to City of Perth and has some other substantial questions - but could support the Bill if Cl 37 removed and questions answered to its satisfaction.

If ALP and Nationals vote against and one Liberal crosses the floor, the votes will be tied 29 for and 29 against. Does the Speaker have a casting vote - and how would he use it? The Speaker should be aware of Denison's Rule.

Denison's rule is a convention, derived from the UK and the House of Commons, that the Speaker's casting vote should always be in favour of further debate or, where no further debate is possible, to vote in favour of the status quo. The principle behind the convention is that change should only occur if an actual majority is in favour of that change.
http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-information-office/p09.pdf
Denison's rule is a guiding principle also in many non-parliamentary bodies that have neutral chairpersons.

Monday, 21 September 2015

What Our Capital City Really Needs

In an earlier post (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/09/why-city-of-perth-bill-is-fatally-flawed.html) we set out the reasons why all of us should be very concerned about the Government's attempt to foist an ill-thought-out and fatally-flawed City of Perth Bill on us in the name of creating a great capital city for WA.

We are aware that simply expressing our concerns will be taken by some as being negative, but in fact we support the creation of a more effective capital city for Western Australia. The current Bill, however, is so flawed that we believe it should be withdrawn or defeated and something better put in its place. 

As a positive contribution to this, the CCCC has developed a framework document for a capital city (attached), which we respectfully request that you consider when responding to the current Bill. The first part of our document reviews practice in all Australian state Capital Cities (no two cities are the same). The last page and a half sets out what we consider to be the essential principles and legislative requirements for a truly great capital city, including involvement of all stakeholders, openness and accountability, and establishment of a means for effective implementation of agreed policies, strategies and plans.
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge

Sunday, 20 September 2015

Why The City of Perth Bill Is Fatally Flawed

We have previously summarised our concerns about the City of Perth Bill (http://capitalcitycitizenscommittee.blogspot.com.au/2015/08/dangers-for-all-local-governments.html) but have refrained from setting out our full arguments until we had been able to talk with as many members of State Parliament as possible.

We also mailed and emailed our detailed documentation to MLAs over the past few weeks.

It now seems likely that the City of Perth Bill will be debated in the Legislative Assembly this week, so it is appropriate to bring our concerns to the attention of a wider audience.
Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge


Tuesday, 28 July 2015

CCCC At South Perth Council

Cecilia Brooke and I spoke on behalf of the Capital City Citizens' Committee at the South Perth Council Meeting last night (Tuesday 28th July). Here is the main part of what we said.

Well Done, South Perth Council

Last night, South Perth City Council voted unanimously to express its strong concerns about a range of aspects of the City of Perth Bill currently before the Legislative Assembly.

Faced with an officer recommendation that Council seek deletion of clause 37 from the Bill and provide commentary on some other aspects of the Bill, Councillors, at the instigation of Cr Colin Cala, transformed their resolution (passed unanimously) into a virtual rejection of the Bill in its entirety, including:

a)    deletion of clause 37* from the City of Perth Bill;
b)    providing commentary on other aspects of the Bill with reference to clauses 19-21** and clauses 12-15***
c)    expressing  Council’s concern with the uncertainties, ambiguities and lack of procedural  fairness, clear process and accountability that is currently contained in other clauses of the Bill, especially with regard to clauses 17 and 18****; clauses 28 and 29*****; and clause 27******;
d)    requesting in the strongest terms, that the government consider a re-draft of the Bill in order to provide more clarity in its provisions and inclusiveness in its application;
e)    that while seeking to establish a more effective Capital City, the Bill do so without disadvantaging the rights and financial sustainability of adjacent local authorities.

Cr Kevin Trent added an amendment, also passed unanimously, that the resolution and the reasons for it be communicated to all local Councils in Western Australia. This should enliven debate and discussion at the WALGA Conference and Annual General Meeting next week.

Congratulations to the South Perth Council (and Cr Cala in particular) for being the first Council to take a strong stand on the City of Perth Bill, including acknowledging the threats to other local governments and communities, not just their own.

NOTES on the City of Perth Bill

*          Clause 37 requires the Local Government Advisory Board, when assessing proposals affecting the City of Perth, “to have regard to the special significance of the role and responsibilities of the City of Perth that flow from Perth being the capital of Western Australia”, but does not define those roles and responsibilities. This leaves it open to the Minister or the City of Perth to ‘define’ them in any proposal and would aid the annexation of Burswood and the commercial areas of Vincent and Subiaco, to which the City of Perth has already laid claim.

**         Clauses 19-21 make non-resident (property or business owner) voting enrolment not subject to automatic expiry. Instead, the onus is placed on the enrollee to notify of becoming ineligible.

***        Clauses 12-15 establish a City of Perth Committee with mixed elected/administration membership that excludes the key portfolios of transport and planning, has no accountability or defined responsibilities and meets at the behest of the Premier.

****       Clauses 17 and 18 change the boundaries of the City of Perth to include Kings Park, 1800 residents of Subiaco, the QEII Medical Centre and the University of Western Australia. In addition, the river boundary is redrawn at the middle of the river, setting a precedent for shifting management responsibility and costs, currently shared between state and local governments, entirely to local governments.

*****      Clauses 28 and 29 provide powers over Kings Park for the Executive Director, Public Health. “For the purposes of protecting, promoting and improving public health”, the Executive Director, Public Health would have “all the powers and authority of a local government under the Local Government Act, 1995”.

              It does not require a large leap of imagination to see this applying to extension of the QEII Medical Centre (including anciliary medical/health services and even car parking) across Winthrop Avenue into Kings Park.

No rationale has been provided in information about the Bill for this provision.

******     Clause 27 repeals the City of Perth Restructuring Act, 1993, which is the sole instrument establishing the Towns of Victoria Park and Cambridge and the (now) City of Vincent. Repeal of this Act disestablishes those local governments and would open the way for the City of Perth to take over Burswood and commercial areas of Vincent.

Wednesday, 8 July 2015

Welcome to the Capital City Citizens' Committee Blog

The Capital City Citizens' Committee is a self-organising group of concerned citizens who believe that Western Australia deserves a better Capital City than the one that would be created by the current City of Perth Bill, which is primarily a grab for territory by or on behalf of the City of Perth. 

There has been no substantial justification for the inclusion of UWA and the QEII Medical Centre in the City of Perth and no consultation with the 1800 residents of Subiaco who would be arbitrarily moved with those institutions.

The Bill would provide the basis for the City of Perth to lay claim to the Burswood Peninsula and the the commercial areas of Vincent and Subiaco - all of which the City of Perth has previously sought control of. 

The Bill would do nothing to enhance the governance of the City of Perth as Capital City of Western Australia. Amongst other things, it gives unspecified power to the Premier, through the proposed City of Perth Committee, which is not accountable to the Perth City Council, the WA Parliament or the community.

The Capital City belongs to all Western Australians, not just the ratepayers, residents and businesses of the City of Perth. We are all citizens of our capital city.

The Capital City Citizens' Committee is working to ensure the defeat of the current Bill. We are meeting with politicians of all parties to present our concerns to them and to urge them to vote against the current City of Perth Bill.
The current City of Perth Bill cannot be sensibly amended and the only way forward is to defeat it and start again.
The Capital City Citizens' Committee is also working to establish the basis for a truly effective Capital City of which all Western Australians can be proud. We will develop and present what we believe are essential and appropriate principles and provisions for effective Capital City legislation and share these publicly through this blog.